In addition to determining the test strategy, there are three additional decisions that each patient and their family member(s) when consenting for this test:
1) Data Sharing
To help healthcare providers and laboratories deliver better care to patients, laboratories share their interpretation of genetic results. Some level of data can be shared without consent, however sharing of additional information which can be helpful to the interpretation of GWS findings require patient consent:
|
For all individuals undergoing GWS |
For individuals who provide consent |
| What data is shared? |
Gene- and variant-level information, including variant interpretations.
This is confined to the genetic result and the associated genetic diagnosis.
e.g. c.4A>G in the SHOC2 gene; classified as pathogenic for Noonan syndrome |
Gene and variant-level information paired with additional details such as GWS test outcome and phenotype.
This can include genetic test results, associated diagnosis, clinical presentation, and demographic details (such as age, sex, and ethnicity).
e.g. c.4A>G in the SHOC2 gene; classified as pathogenic for Noonan syndrome; identified in a 3 year old male whose GWS test was deemed diagnostic and who was documented to have global developmental delay and a ventricular septal defect |
| How is it shared? |
This data is de-identified: The information that can directly identify the patient has been permanently removed. |
This data is coded (rather than de-identified), meaning all personal identifiers are replaced with a code to protect privacy. |
| With who will this data be shared? |
Healthcare providers, genetic testing laboratories, public databases |
A Clinical Knowledge Network composed of approved diagnostic laboratories collaborating to improve diagnostic accuracy in genomics |
An example of how to discuss this with patients:
To contribute to the knowledge of genetics and help other labs or clinicians, labs can share de-identified genetic data with other institutions, without any additional information about patients. Just like how the lab can use information about whether variants are found in parents to understand results, it is also useful to to know if variants are found in other people that share similar symptoms or that do not have any health or developmental concerns (e.g. healthy parents). Having access to this information can help labs to interpret your test results.
You can decide if you would allow the lab to share such information about you with other diagnostic laboratories. If you agree, this would allow the lab to share information about variants found in you, alongside additional details like symptoms, sex, age, and result of your GWS test. This data is coded, meaning that personal identifiers are removed and does not include identifiers such as name, address, etc. Other labs would not be able to contact you.
2) Secondary and Incidental Findings
When GWS is performed, medically actionable findings in genes that are not related to the primary medical conditions for which the test has been requested may also be reported. These include secondary findings and incidental findings, which can cause other medical conditions during childhood and/or later in life.
- Secondary findings (SF) are pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants in list of genes defined by the American College of American Genetics and Genomics (ACMG). The conditions associated with these genes are considered medically actionable.
- When SF are identified, clear medical recommendations can be made to reduce the risk of the associated condition impacting a person’s health in the future. The list of conditions are defined as actionable in childhood or actionable in adulthood.
- Through genome-wide sequencing analysis, SFs can be actively sought in the proband. The analysis for SF is only performed in the proband. These are identified in up to 5% of cases.
- If a SF is identified in a proband, family members participating in GWS may choose to learn about the inheritance of the secondary finding identified in the proband and have the report indicate if the secondary finding(s) is also present in a parent (if also submitted for testing).
- SFs that are only present in a parent or sibling, but not in the proband, will not be identified.
- Incidental findings (IF): Occasionally, findings expected or known to be disease-causing that are identified in a gene not included in the ACMG gene list may also be reported when considered to be medically actionable. These are called incidental findings.
For more information on the secondary findings reported through GSO, visit the Secondary Findings page.
For individuals undergoing GWS in Ontario, the reporting of SF (and IF) depends on the age of the proband (below or above the age of 18 years), their capacity to make medical decisions, and their preference:
An example of how to discuss this with patients:
This test looks at all genes, the main goal will be to find an explanation for your/your child’s condition. However, the lab can also look through a list of genes which are not related to their condition, but which are considered “medically actionable”. Findings in these genes are called secondary findings. For these findings, preventative surveillance or treatment would be available. Examples include conditions that increase the risk for heart disease or cancer. Variants of uncertain significance in these genes are not reported.
For children (≤18 years of age): Any secondary findings that are actionable in childhood will be reported. However, for conditions that are only actionable in adulthood, you can decide whether you would want to know about a secondary finding result that would only impact you/your child in adulthood. An example would be a breast cancer predisposition syndrome that would not be expected to occur or lead to medical recommendations in someone until they are an adult. Would you like to receive these types of results? This analysis will not be done in other family members included in this test, however if a secondary finding is identified in you/your child, they can decide whether they would like to know they also have the same secondary finding.
For adult patients (>18 years of age, with capacity to decide): Having the lab report secondary findings on you is optional. Would you like to receive these results? This analysis will only be done in you, however, in the event where a secondary finding is identified in you, family members included in the test can decide whether they would like to know if they also have the same finding.
This is a personal decision. There is no right or wrong choice.
3) Recontact for future research
GSO can serve as a mechanism to enable identification of eligible participants for research studies:
- Providing consent for recontact is optional and does not imply consent to participation in research.
- Patients (or their substitute decision maker) must decide if they agree to being contacted by the GSO laboratory about approved potential future research studies.
- Research studies could include (but are not limited to) studies that aim to better understand rare diseases, describe the natural history of a condition, or clinical trials.
An example of how to discuss this with patients:
Patients who receive GWS may be eligible to participate in future research studies. Would you be okay if the laboratory reaches out to you in the future about research opportunities?
Consenting to being recontacted does not commit you to participating in a study, but it allows the laboratory where this is performed to let you know about research studies.
If you are contacted, you can decide if you want to be connected to the research team to hear more about the study to decide if you want to join. If the specific study isn’t of interest to you, you could say no at that time.